Skip to main content
Hussain & Gutierrez

May 28, 2023

When an asylum petition is denied

Given the dire circumstances an asylum-seeker can be in, a lot can be riding on what happens with their asylum petition.

Person writing the word Asylum on a chalkboard.

On this page

Among the reasons a person may desire to come to the U.S. is to escape persecution in their home country. This could include things like religious or political persecution. One immigration option that may be available to individuals fleeing such persecution is to apply for asylum here in America.

Given the dire circumstances an asylum-seeker can be in, a lot can be riding on what happens with their asylum petition. Now, sometimes, immigration officials’ initial decision on such a petition doesn’t go the way an asylum-seeker was hoping. When their asylum petition has been denied, a person may be very worried about their future and fearful that they may never be able to find a safe and stable living situation.

What Type of Asylum Decision Did You Receive?

The next step depends on the decision and which agency issued it. A USCIS referral of an affirmative asylum application to immigration court is not a final denial: the immigration judge can consider the claim. A final denial by a USCIS asylum office generally cannot be appealed to the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, although a motion or a new application may be available in limited circumstances. An immigration judge’s denial may be appealable to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) if the required procedures and deadline are met.

Read the Notice and Check the Deadline

If an immigration judge denied asylum, the Department of Justice states that a BIA appeal on Form EOIR-26 ordinarily must be received within 30 calendar days of the judge’s oral decision or mailing of the written decision; deadlines and procedures are different for other kinds of decisions. Do not assume that filing a motion will automatically stop removal. Read the actual decision, preserve all notices, and seek qualified immigration advice promptly. Official resources include USCIS affirmative asylum decisions and DOJ/EOIR guidance on appealing an immigration judge’s decision.

A denial, referral, or court decision can carry urgent consequences. Contact the Van Nuys office to discuss the notice and ask whether the firm handles the particular type of asylum-related proceeding or appeal involved.

Free consultationRequest a consultationCall now888-997-3701